<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss version="2.0"
	xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/"
	xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/"
	xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom"
	xmlns:sy="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/syndication/"
	xmlns:series="https://publishpress.com/"
	
	>
<channel>
	<title>
	Comments on: Deus Ex Machinas And The Plot Implications Of Divinity	</title>
	<atom:link href="https://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/the-plot-implications-of-divinity/feed/" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml" />
	<link>https://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/the-plot-implications-of-divinity/</link>
	<description>Expert advice on creating and running exceptional campaigns. Winner,&#160;Silver&#160;Ennie 2016 for Best RPG Blog!</description>
	<lastBuildDate>Mon, 05 Nov 2012 16:34:32 +0000</lastBuildDate>
	<sy:updatePeriod>
	hourly	</sy:updatePeriod>
	<sy:updateFrequency>
	1	</sy:updateFrequency>
	
	<item>
		<title>
		By: Mike		</title>
		<link>https://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/the-plot-implications-of-divinity/comment-page-1/#comment-28023</link>

		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Mike]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Mon, 05 Nov 2012 16:34:32 +0000</pubDate>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">http://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/?p=5392#comment-28023</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[In reply to &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/the-plot-implications-of-divinity/comment-page-1/#comment-28017&quot;&gt;Dan H&lt;/a&gt;.

@Dan H: Certainly, avoiding the question in the way you describe is a valid alternative, especially if you are willing to dig into the harder questions when the answers become necessary. I would argue that being able to do so at your leasure is better than doing it under deadline pressure because the answers are needed &quot;right now&quot;, though.

Yes, many of the questions are game mechanics - but they are questions about which the established rules do not give answers, so that puts the ball back into the DM&#039;s court.]]></description>
			<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In reply to <a href="https://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/the-plot-implications-of-divinity/comment-page-1/#comment-28017">Dan H</a>.</p>
<p>@Dan H: Certainly, avoiding the question in the way you describe is a valid alternative, especially if you are willing to dig into the harder questions when the answers become necessary. I would argue that being able to do so at your leasure is better than doing it under deadline pressure because the answers are needed &#8220;right now&#8221;, though.</p>
<p>Yes, many of the questions are game mechanics &#8211; but they are questions about which the established rules do not give answers, so that puts the ball back into the DM&#8217;s court.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>
		By: Dan H		</title>
		<link>https://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/the-plot-implications-of-divinity/comment-page-1/#comment-28017</link>

		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Dan H]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Mon, 05 Nov 2012 15:29:06 +0000</pubDate>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">http://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/?p=5392#comment-28017</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[@Mike

I think we&#039;re pretty much in agreement about most things, except that from a personal perspective I tend to think of the everyday questions (chief amongst them being &quot;what do followers of my God *actually believe*?&quot;) to be more important than the higher level questions like &quot;what are the Gods, actuallly&quot; or &quot;where does divine power come from.&quot;

To borrow some terminology from the Philosophy of Science, I basically consider myself a bit of an instrumentalist here, in that I think the question of what the Gods *are* is much less important than the question of how the Gods *behave*. Essentially I&#039;m happy to accept a relatively circular argument here - if the Gods in your setting don&#039;t intervene to stop their worshipers being slaughtered, then I&#039;m prefectly happy to just accept that intervening to stop the slaughter of their worshipers is *just not what Gods do*. What I think is far more important in that case is explaining how the *worshipers* of that god deal with the fact that their god lets them be slaughtered.

I&#039;d also add that a lot of your questions seem to be game mechanical ones - some explicitly so (like &quot;do I get experience for converting heathens to the worship of my deity&quot;). I wouldn&#039;t want to answer the question of where Clerical spells &quot;come from&quot; because I tend to view them as an abstraction designed to represent a wide variety of supernatural powers wielded by priestly characters.

For what it&#039;s worth, my current AD&#038;D campaign has involved a player character becoming a God, and so I&#039;ve had to work through a fair number of these questions, but I&#039;ve always done it in a more or less ad-hoc way, and there&#039;s a certain extent to which I don&#039;t think hard, defined answers are the way forward.]]></description>
			<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>@Mike</p>
<p>I think we&#8217;re pretty much in agreement about most things, except that from a personal perspective I tend to think of the everyday questions (chief amongst them being &#8220;what do followers of my God *actually believe*?&#8221;) to be more important than the higher level questions like &#8220;what are the Gods, actuallly&#8221; or &#8220;where does divine power come from.&#8221;</p>
<p>To borrow some terminology from the Philosophy of Science, I basically consider myself a bit of an instrumentalist here, in that I think the question of what the Gods *are* is much less important than the question of how the Gods *behave*. Essentially I&#8217;m happy to accept a relatively circular argument here &#8211; if the Gods in your setting don&#8217;t intervene to stop their worshipers being slaughtered, then I&#8217;m prefectly happy to just accept that intervening to stop the slaughter of their worshipers is *just not what Gods do*. What I think is far more important in that case is explaining how the *worshipers* of that god deal with the fact that their god lets them be slaughtered.</p>
<p>I&#8217;d also add that a lot of your questions seem to be game mechanical ones &#8211; some explicitly so (like &#8220;do I get experience for converting heathens to the worship of my deity&#8221;). I wouldn&#8217;t want to answer the question of where Clerical spells &#8220;come from&#8221; because I tend to view them as an abstraction designed to represent a wide variety of supernatural powers wielded by priestly characters.</p>
<p>For what it&#8217;s worth, my current AD&amp;D campaign has involved a player character becoming a God, and so I&#8217;ve had to work through a fair number of these questions, but I&#8217;ve always done it in a more or less ad-hoc way, and there&#8217;s a certain extent to which I don&#8217;t think hard, defined answers are the way forward.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>
		By: Mike		</title>
		<link>https://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/the-plot-implications-of-divinity/comment-page-1/#comment-27872</link>

		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Mike]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Thu, 01 Nov 2012 02:14:43 +0000</pubDate>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">http://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/?p=5392#comment-27872</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[@Dan H: You&#039;re right, and your most recent reply certainly clarifies a few things. We seem to be approaching the question from different points in the campaign definition track. You use the Greco-Roman example and then suggest that the nature of the Greco-Roman gods is such that they define themselves by that nature as not interfering casually in the lives of mortals.

Setting aside differing interpretations of the likelyhood of meddling for its own sake on the part of Greco-Roman deities (the Greeks and Romans certainly thought they spent their time doing nothing but interfere and intervene, mostly for their own amusement), I would consider being &quot;Greco-Roman Deities&quot; as the answer to the questions I pose. You assume that this decision has already been made.

When you first crack open the rulebooks to create a campaign, the only things that you know about the deities are that they provide magic to Clerics. And a lot of GMs - aside from furnishing them with names, descriptions, and mythic portfolios - go no further than that.

From my point of view, I can&#039;t understand deities not getting involved in major events that threaten their lives or the lives of the bulk of their followers. That automatically means that the PCs, who by virtue of what they are are going to be at the centre of big events within the campaign, are more likely than most to get divine attention - one way or another. But maybe I&#039;m a closet interventionist at heart :-)

If you havn&#039;t answered the sort of questions that I pose, how do you answer player questions like &quot;What is my god&#039;s theological doctrine? What am I required to do and what am I not permitted to do? How do I worship, where, and how often? What is the afterlife? &lt;em&gt;Is&lt;/em&gt; there an afterlife? What are undead? Do I have any enemies just because of my choice of Deity? Do I have any allies for the same reason? There are spells that force a deity to answer specific questions in specific ways - what have the priests of my religion been able to learn by asking the Gods about themselves? Hw do you make Holy Water? If I do [X] to Holy Water, is is still usable? Can I make it more easily transportable by dehydrating it into a powder? Can I make it more effective by concentrating it, like Acid? Can I create new clerical spells? Where did the existing Clerical spells come from? Does anything happen to me if I build a shrine to a deity I don&#039;t like and then destroy or desecrate it? Can &lt;em&gt;I&lt;/em&gt; become a God? Do I get experience for converting Heathens to the worship of my deity?&quot; ...and on and on - all of which I have been asked in games that I have run.

It&#039;s your final paragraph, though, that is most telling. Not assuming that the Gods are omnipotent, omniscient, omnipresent, omnibenevolent does not mean assuming that they are none of those things - it means deciding based on other factors within your campaign whether or not they are any of these things, and if not, how close to it they come.

And if they are all of those things but still don&#039;t intervene to solve problems, you definitely need to explain &lt;em&gt;that!&lt;/em&gt;]]></description>
			<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>@Dan H: You&#8217;re right, and your most recent reply certainly clarifies a few things. We seem to be approaching the question from different points in the campaign definition track. You use the Greco-Roman example and then suggest that the nature of the Greco-Roman gods is such that they define themselves by that nature as not interfering casually in the lives of mortals.</p>
<p>Setting aside differing interpretations of the likelyhood of meddling for its own sake on the part of Greco-Roman deities (the Greeks and Romans certainly thought they spent their time doing nothing but interfere and intervene, mostly for their own amusement), I would consider being &#8220;Greco-Roman Deities&#8221; as the answer to the questions I pose. You assume that this decision has already been made.</p>
<p>When you first crack open the rulebooks to create a campaign, the only things that you know about the deities are that they provide magic to Clerics. And a lot of GMs &#8211; aside from furnishing them with names, descriptions, and mythic portfolios &#8211; go no further than that.</p>
<p>From my point of view, I can&#8217;t understand deities not getting involved in major events that threaten their lives or the lives of the bulk of their followers. That automatically means that the PCs, who by virtue of what they are are going to be at the centre of big events within the campaign, are more likely than most to get divine attention &#8211; one way or another. But maybe I&#8217;m a closet interventionist at heart :-)</p>
<p>If you havn&#8217;t answered the sort of questions that I pose, how do you answer player questions like &#8220;What is my god&#8217;s theological doctrine? What am I required to do and what am I not permitted to do? How do I worship, where, and how often? What is the afterlife? <em>Is</em> there an afterlife? What are undead? Do I have any enemies just because of my choice of Deity? Do I have any allies for the same reason? There are spells that force a deity to answer specific questions in specific ways &#8211; what have the priests of my religion been able to learn by asking the Gods about themselves? Hw do you make Holy Water? If I do [X] to Holy Water, is is still usable? Can I make it more easily transportable by dehydrating it into a powder? Can I make it more effective by concentrating it, like Acid? Can I create new clerical spells? Where did the existing Clerical spells come from? Does anything happen to me if I build a shrine to a deity I don&#8217;t like and then destroy or desecrate it? Can <em>I</em> become a God? Do I get experience for converting Heathens to the worship of my deity?&#8221; &#8230;and on and on &#8211; all of which I have been asked in games that I have run.</p>
<p>It&#8217;s your final paragraph, though, that is most telling. Not assuming that the Gods are omnipotent, omniscient, omnipresent, omnibenevolent does not mean assuming that they are none of those things &#8211; it means deciding based on other factors within your campaign whether or not they are any of these things, and if not, how close to it they come.</p>
<p>And if they are all of those things but still don&#8217;t intervene to solve problems, you definitely need to explain <em>that!</em></p>
]]></content:encoded>
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>
		By: Dan H		</title>
		<link>https://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/the-plot-implications-of-divinity/comment-page-1/#comment-27859</link>

		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Dan H]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Wed, 31 Oct 2012 12:32:49 +0000</pubDate>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">http://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/?p=5392#comment-27859</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[I think we&#039;re still talking a little bit at cross purposes here.

I absolutely agree that the default assumptions I&#039;m talking about apply only to a Judeo-Christian deity, but those are the only set of assumptions I can understand which support your assertion that &quot;if [the Gods] were ‘real’, you would expect them to intervene. The narrative burden then shifts to answering the question of why they did not do so&quot;.

If we are *not* assuming that Gods, by definition, are benevolent, omnipotent, omniscient, and omnipresent, then we are do not need to explain why the gods do not solve all of the problems the PCs face. If, as you say, you reject the assumption that Gods are necessarily omnipotent, necessarily omnipresent, or for that matter necessarily benevolent, then the entire problem simply ceases to exist. The GM no more needs to explain why the Gods do not intervene to solve a particular problem than they need to explain why - say - the King, or a random higher-level adventuring party, does not solve that problem.

If I&#039;m running a Greco-Roman inspired D&#038;D campaign, and my PCs are hired to clear out a nest of kobolds living in a hillside, I don&#039;t have to come up with any special reason that Ares hasn&#039;t already shown up and killed the kobolds himself,. There is no reason to assume that killing off a random tribe of kobolds is the sort of thing that Ares would even bother doing in the first place.

*Unless* you are assuming omnipotent, omniscient, omnipresent, omnibenevolent Gods, you absolutely do *not* have to posit any specific reasons for the Gods not solving problems for people. You only have to explain why the Gods *don&#039;t* directly intervene in mortal affairs if you have already established that they *do*, which is surely needless repetition of labour.

I think you&#039;re also misconstruing my use of &quot;non-interventionist&quot;. I&#039;m not suggesting that I think Gods are assumed, by default, to follow some kind of Star Trek Prime Directive, where they arbitrarily preclude themselves from intervening personally in the affairs of mortals. Rather, I simply mean that the Gods *in practice* do not intervene *directly and personally* in the affairs of mortals *on a regular basis*. Your proposed default assumption is - I think - just non-interventionism with a specific explanation: the Gods don&#039;t interfere directly in the lives of mortals because the opposing faction of Gods stops them.

You could imagine a fantasy setting in which the Gods are *not* non-interventionist, in which they genuinely do appear, in person, in front of ordinary mortals on a regular basis, and solve their problems. This would create an *extremely* divergent setting, in which most of the institutions mortals have created to help themselves would not exist (why bother farming if the Goddess of the Harvest can and will just give you food).

This isn&#039;t to say that working out how Gods work in your setting isn&#039;t an interesting and useful exercise, but I don&#039;t think your stated purpose - explaining why the Gods do not simply show up to provide Deus ex Machina solutions to the PCs&#039; problems - requires it. All you need for that is to *not* assume omnipotent, omniscient, omnipresent, omnibenevolent deities.]]></description>
			<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>I think we&#8217;re still talking a little bit at cross purposes here.</p>
<p>I absolutely agree that the default assumptions I&#8217;m talking about apply only to a Judeo-Christian deity, but those are the only set of assumptions I can understand which support your assertion that &#8220;if [the Gods] were ‘real’, you would expect them to intervene. The narrative burden then shifts to answering the question of why they did not do so&#8221;.</p>
<p>If we are *not* assuming that Gods, by definition, are benevolent, omnipotent, omniscient, and omnipresent, then we are do not need to explain why the gods do not solve all of the problems the PCs face. If, as you say, you reject the assumption that Gods are necessarily omnipotent, necessarily omnipresent, or for that matter necessarily benevolent, then the entire problem simply ceases to exist. The GM no more needs to explain why the Gods do not intervene to solve a particular problem than they need to explain why &#8211; say &#8211; the King, or a random higher-level adventuring party, does not solve that problem.</p>
<p>If I&#8217;m running a Greco-Roman inspired D&amp;D campaign, and my PCs are hired to clear out a nest of kobolds living in a hillside, I don&#8217;t have to come up with any special reason that Ares hasn&#8217;t already shown up and killed the kobolds himself,. There is no reason to assume that killing off a random tribe of kobolds is the sort of thing that Ares would even bother doing in the first place.</p>
<p>*Unless* you are assuming omnipotent, omniscient, omnipresent, omnibenevolent Gods, you absolutely do *not* have to posit any specific reasons for the Gods not solving problems for people. You only have to explain why the Gods *don&#8217;t* directly intervene in mortal affairs if you have already established that they *do*, which is surely needless repetition of labour.</p>
<p>I think you&#8217;re also misconstruing my use of &#8220;non-interventionist&#8221;. I&#8217;m not suggesting that I think Gods are assumed, by default, to follow some kind of Star Trek Prime Directive, where they arbitrarily preclude themselves from intervening personally in the affairs of mortals. Rather, I simply mean that the Gods *in practice* do not intervene *directly and personally* in the affairs of mortals *on a regular basis*. Your proposed default assumption is &#8211; I think &#8211; just non-interventionism with a specific explanation: the Gods don&#8217;t interfere directly in the lives of mortals because the opposing faction of Gods stops them.</p>
<p>You could imagine a fantasy setting in which the Gods are *not* non-interventionist, in which they genuinely do appear, in person, in front of ordinary mortals on a regular basis, and solve their problems. This would create an *extremely* divergent setting, in which most of the institutions mortals have created to help themselves would not exist (why bother farming if the Goddess of the Harvest can and will just give you food).</p>
<p>This isn&#8217;t to say that working out how Gods work in your setting isn&#8217;t an interesting and useful exercise, but I don&#8217;t think your stated purpose &#8211; explaining why the Gods do not simply show up to provide Deus ex Machina solutions to the PCs&#8217; problems &#8211; requires it. All you need for that is to *not* assume omnipotent, omniscient, omnipresent, omnibenevolent deities.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>
		By: Mike		</title>
		<link>https://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/the-plot-implications-of-divinity/comment-page-1/#comment-27844</link>

		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Mike]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Wed, 31 Oct 2012 03:59:38 +0000</pubDate>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">http://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/?p=5392#comment-27844</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[@Dan - The quote you give and the translation thereof is more complete than the one quoted by Wikipedia. If the translation they offered, and which I paraphrase in the second paragraph of the article had read what you have just quoted this would have been a very different article! The quote which inspired the article had no mention of a qualifying condition - &quot;unless a knot show up that be worthy of such an untangler&quot;, and it was that absense that led to the article as written. What it seeks to do, after all, is to provide just such a qualifying condition in a form appropriate to an RPG.

I am certainly not arguing that the Gods should solve all the problems - that&#039;s the PCs job, they are the centre of attention within the Campaign! I &lt;em&gt;am&lt;/em&gt; saying that they have the &lt;em&gt;capability&lt;/em&gt; of doing so, and that the GM needs to have good reasons why they don&#039;t.

I disagree as to the default assumption. My default assumption would be that apparantly benevolent deities would solve every problem if they could but there are good reasons why they are unable to do so.

Assumptions your proposed default condition makes for all deities include benevolence (explicitly), omnipotence (explicitly), omnipresence (implied), omniscience (implied), and lack of opposition (implied). Those all describe a Christian deity but say nothing about Norse, Egyptian, Greco-Roman, Finnish, Japanese, Chinese, Korean, or (for that matter) Venusian mythos deities.

I can and do challenge all of these as default assumptions. They are just one extreme of a range of possibilities. Certainly D&#038;D, Pathfinder, Superhero Comics &#038; Games, etc make no such default assumptions - rather, they view the gods as limited, as flawed, as posessing agendas beyond a simplistic &#039;good vs evil&#039;, and with equal or superior opposing forces either in power or in numbers or (potentially) by some other measure.

If an essentially christian theological structure is part of the structure of the game world created by the GM, then certainly non-interventionism is one possible explanation for why the Gods don&#039;t solve every problem, leaving the PCs with nothing to do. It&#039;s not the only one, though.

My default assumption would be that there is an overall power balance between pro-mortal and anti-mortal theological factions, each striving for whatever miniscule advantages they can achieve - thereby letting the PCs, although insignificant in relative power level, make a lasting difference to their world.

Ultimately, your proposal is a satisfactory one for a low-fantasy game - but it doesn&#039;t work in a high-fantasy setting, or even a mid-level fantasy setting such as the ones employed by most RPGs.]]></description>
			<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>@Dan &#8211; The quote you give and the translation thereof is more complete than the one quoted by Wikipedia. If the translation they offered, and which I paraphrase in the second paragraph of the article had read what you have just quoted this would have been a very different article! The quote which inspired the article had no mention of a qualifying condition &#8211; &#8220;unless a knot show up that be worthy of such an untangler&#8221;, and it was that absense that led to the article as written. What it seeks to do, after all, is to provide just such a qualifying condition in a form appropriate to an RPG.</p>
<p>I am certainly not arguing that the Gods should solve all the problems &#8211; that&#8217;s the PCs job, they are the centre of attention within the Campaign! I <em>am</em> saying that they have the <em>capability</em> of doing so, and that the GM needs to have good reasons why they don&#8217;t.</p>
<p>I disagree as to the default assumption. My default assumption would be that apparantly benevolent deities would solve every problem if they could but there are good reasons why they are unable to do so.</p>
<p>Assumptions your proposed default condition makes for all deities include benevolence (explicitly), omnipotence (explicitly), omnipresence (implied), omniscience (implied), and lack of opposition (implied). Those all describe a Christian deity but say nothing about Norse, Egyptian, Greco-Roman, Finnish, Japanese, Chinese, Korean, or (for that matter) Venusian mythos deities.</p>
<p>I can and do challenge all of these as default assumptions. They are just one extreme of a range of possibilities. Certainly D&amp;D, Pathfinder, Superhero Comics &amp; Games, etc make no such default assumptions &#8211; rather, they view the gods as limited, as flawed, as posessing agendas beyond a simplistic &#8216;good vs evil&#8217;, and with equal or superior opposing forces either in power or in numbers or (potentially) by some other measure.</p>
<p>If an essentially christian theological structure is part of the structure of the game world created by the GM, then certainly non-interventionism is one possible explanation for why the Gods don&#8217;t solve every problem, leaving the PCs with nothing to do. It&#8217;s not the only one, though.</p>
<p>My default assumption would be that there is an overall power balance between pro-mortal and anti-mortal theological factions, each striving for whatever miniscule advantages they can achieve &#8211; thereby letting the PCs, although insignificant in relative power level, make a lasting difference to their world.</p>
<p>Ultimately, your proposal is a satisfactory one for a low-fantasy game &#8211; but it doesn&#8217;t work in a high-fantasy setting, or even a mid-level fantasy setting such as the ones employed by most RPGs.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>
		By: Dan H		</title>
		<link>https://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/the-plot-implications-of-divinity/comment-page-1/#comment-27836</link>

		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Dan H]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Tue, 30 Oct 2012 22:28:55 +0000</pubDate>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">http://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/?p=5392#comment-27836</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[@Mike

As you say, I think we&#039;re mostly agreeing here, I&#039;m just still confused as to why you think the original criticism of the Deus ex Machina (which you quote yourself as suggesting that poets should never &quot;resort to a god from the machine&quot; to resolve their plots) was based on the idea that the Gods were fictional, given that it was almost certainly voiced by somebody who believed that the Gods literally existed.

Horace&#039;s admonition against the Deus ex Machina was not &quot;don&#039;t use divine intervention to resolve your plots, because Gods don&#039;t exist&quot;, rather it was: &quot;Nec deus intersit, nisi dignus vindice nodus&quot; - which according to good old wiki translates as &quot;That a god not intervene, unless a knot show up that be worthy of such an untangler&quot;. Horace&#039;s problem with the Deus ex Machina wasn&#039;t that he didn&#039;t believe in Gods, it was that he didn&#039;t believe that Gods went around solving problems for mortals.

Thinking about it, where we disagree is when you say:

&quot;After all, if [the Gods] were ‘real’, you would expect them to intervene. The narrative burden then shifts to answering the question of why they did not do so.&quot;

I simply don&#039;t think this is correct.

You seem to be arguing that if Gods exist, the default assumption must be that they can and will solve all problems, but historically this has not been the way Gods are assumed to behave, either in real mythology or in fiction.

The default assumption, even in a setting in which Gods are real, must surely be relatively non-interventionist deities. Otherwise your world would look completely unrecognizable, as benevolent, omnipotent, interventionist deities would have solved every problem any human being had ever had since the dawn of time.

There is no narrative burden to explain *why* Gods don&#039;t intervene in the day-to-day affairs of mortals, any more than there exists a narrative burden to explain why gravity pulls down instead of up.]]></description>
			<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>@Mike</p>
<p>As you say, I think we&#8217;re mostly agreeing here, I&#8217;m just still confused as to why you think the original criticism of the Deus ex Machina (which you quote yourself as suggesting that poets should never &#8220;resort to a god from the machine&#8221; to resolve their plots) was based on the idea that the Gods were fictional, given that it was almost certainly voiced by somebody who believed that the Gods literally existed.</p>
<p>Horace&#8217;s admonition against the Deus ex Machina was not &#8220;don&#8217;t use divine intervention to resolve your plots, because Gods don&#8217;t exist&#8221;, rather it was: &#8220;Nec deus intersit, nisi dignus vindice nodus&#8221; &#8211; which according to good old wiki translates as &#8220;That a god not intervene, unless a knot show up that be worthy of such an untangler&#8221;. Horace&#8217;s problem with the Deus ex Machina wasn&#8217;t that he didn&#8217;t believe in Gods, it was that he didn&#8217;t believe that Gods went around solving problems for mortals.</p>
<p>Thinking about it, where we disagree is when you say:</p>
<p>&#8220;After all, if [the Gods] were ‘real’, you would expect them to intervene. The narrative burden then shifts to answering the question of why they did not do so.&#8221;</p>
<p>I simply don&#8217;t think this is correct.</p>
<p>You seem to be arguing that if Gods exist, the default assumption must be that they can and will solve all problems, but historically this has not been the way Gods are assumed to behave, either in real mythology or in fiction.</p>
<p>The default assumption, even in a setting in which Gods are real, must surely be relatively non-interventionist deities. Otherwise your world would look completely unrecognizable, as benevolent, omnipotent, interventionist deities would have solved every problem any human being had ever had since the dawn of time.</p>
<p>There is no narrative burden to explain *why* Gods don&#8217;t intervene in the day-to-day affairs of mortals, any more than there exists a narrative burden to explain why gravity pulls down instead of up.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>
		By: Mike		</title>
		<link>https://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/the-plot-implications-of-divinity/comment-page-1/#comment-27833</link>

		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Mike]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Tue, 30 Oct 2012 18:48:43 +0000</pubDate>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">http://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/?p=5392#comment-27833</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[In reply to &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/the-plot-implications-of-divinity/comment-page-1/#comment-27827&quot;&gt;Andy&lt;/a&gt;.

@Andy: There is a difference between a different state or level of consciousness and living in a different world. Your arguement is circular reasoning and can be summed up, &quot;The Gods percieve the world differently because they have a different nature, being transcendant, and that difference in perception changes the way they think and that in turn makes them different by nature.&quot;

You seem to be assuming that deities are either transcendant or powered-up humans; I would submit that there are more possibilities than that. Transcendance is a quality associated with Christian beliefs, almost every other theology throughout human existance has fallen somewhere in between mortals and full transcendance.

I can also picture a transcendant deity who does not posess in full measure the three &quot;Omni&#039;s&quot; (Omnipotence, Omniscience, and Omnipresence). And without those three, especially Omnipresence and Omniscience, your arguement fails, in whole or in part. It all comes back to the questions of what are the deities in your game (as opposed tp &quot;who&quot; they are) and how do their powers work? Is immortality enough to define one as a deity? Is Immortality a necessary quality for a God? If so, how do you regard the Norse Gods?

Yes, there are some beings who would have a transcendant thought process that makes them utterly alien to our comprehension of thought, and thereby by definition they must view the world very differently. But that&#039;s not necessarily the case for all possible Gods in a game. There are other answers.

Furthermore, the thought processes in question can&#039;t be too alien - because the person simulating their behavior and decision-making process is all too human.]]></description>
			<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In reply to <a href="https://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/the-plot-implications-of-divinity/comment-page-1/#comment-27827">Andy</a>.</p>
<p>@Andy: There is a difference between a different state or level of consciousness and living in a different world. Your arguement is circular reasoning and can be summed up, &#8220;The Gods percieve the world differently because they have a different nature, being transcendant, and that difference in perception changes the way they think and that in turn makes them different by nature.&#8221;</p>
<p>You seem to be assuming that deities are either transcendant or powered-up humans; I would submit that there are more possibilities than that. Transcendance is a quality associated with Christian beliefs, almost every other theology throughout human existance has fallen somewhere in between mortals and full transcendance.</p>
<p>I can also picture a transcendant deity who does not posess in full measure the three &#8220;Omni&#8217;s&#8221; (Omnipotence, Omniscience, and Omnipresence). And without those three, especially Omnipresence and Omniscience, your arguement fails, in whole or in part. It all comes back to the questions of what are the deities in your game (as opposed tp &#8220;who&#8221; they are) and how do their powers work? Is immortality enough to define one as a deity? Is Immortality a necessary quality for a God? If so, how do you regard the Norse Gods?</p>
<p>Yes, there are some beings who would have a transcendant thought process that makes them utterly alien to our comprehension of thought, and thereby by definition they must view the world very differently. But that&#8217;s not necessarily the case for all possible Gods in a game. There are other answers.</p>
<p>Furthermore, the thought processes in question can&#8217;t be too alien &#8211; because the person simulating their behavior and decision-making process is all too human.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>
		By: Andy		</title>
		<link>https://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/the-plot-implications-of-divinity/comment-page-1/#comment-27827</link>

		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Andy]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Tue, 30 Oct 2012 15:16:10 +0000</pubDate>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">http://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/?p=5392#comment-27827</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[@Mike: The main reason I say that has to do with the nature of said deities. When you&#039;re talking about some manner of &quot;transcendant&quot; deity (such as a more primal god--I&#039;m leaving the Greek/Roman powered-up humans out of this, as they&#039;re easy enough to analyze), that being necessarily perceives reality in a different fashion, and has a totally different perspective than us. Even if they try to think like us, they won&#039;t 100% be able to.

Case in point--Doctor Manhattan from Watchmen, who no longer perceives time in a chronological fashion. And he&#039;s a mild example.]]></description>
			<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>@Mike: The main reason I say that has to do with the nature of said deities. When you&#8217;re talking about some manner of &#8220;transcendant&#8221; deity (such as a more primal god&#8211;I&#8217;m leaving the Greek/Roman powered-up humans out of this, as they&#8217;re easy enough to analyze), that being necessarily perceives reality in a different fashion, and has a totally different perspective than us. Even if they try to think like us, they won&#8217;t 100% be able to.</p>
<p>Case in point&#8211;Doctor Manhattan from Watchmen, who no longer perceives time in a chronological fashion. And he&#8217;s a mild example.</p>
]]></content:encoded>
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>
		By: Mike		</title>
		<link>https://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/the-plot-implications-of-divinity/comment-page-1/#comment-27806</link>

		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Mike]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Tue, 30 Oct 2012 00:01:16 +0000</pubDate>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">http://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/?p=5392#comment-27806</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[In reply to &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/the-plot-implications-of-divinity/comment-page-1/#comment-27798&quot;&gt;Andy&lt;/a&gt;.

@Andy: I wouldn&#039;t say &lt;em&gt;necessarily,&lt;/em&gt; because I think there are other solutions to that problem, but that&#039;s another of those big questions that need to be answered!]]></description>
			<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In reply to <a href="https://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/the-plot-implications-of-divinity/comment-page-1/#comment-27798">Andy</a>.</p>
<p>@Andy: I wouldn&#8217;t say <em>necessarily,</em> because I think there are other solutions to that problem, but that&#8217;s another of those big questions that need to be answered!</p>
]]></content:encoded>
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>
		By: Mike		</title>
		<link>https://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/the-plot-implications-of-divinity/comment-page-1/#comment-27805</link>

		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Mike]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Mon, 29 Oct 2012 23:59:23 +0000</pubDate>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">http://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/?p=5392#comment-27805</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[In reply to &lt;a href=&quot;https://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/the-plot-implications-of-divinity/comment-page-1/#comment-27797&quot;&gt;Dan H&lt;/a&gt;.

@Dan H: You wrote: 
&lt;blockquote&gt;If the criticism of a deus ex machina hinged on the assumption that deities aren’t real, it would not be possible to apply the term to phenomena which are physically possible in the real world, but it is.&lt;/blockquote&gt;

I&#039;m afraid I have to sideways sort-of disagree with that statement. The original criticism hinged on the assumption that deities aren&#039;t real and was a very specific complaint. The usage has since been broadened and generalized to include phenomena which are physically possible in the real world, such as your random millionaire.

Criticism of the literary device beyond that initial complaint are valid as far as they go (I still think an out-of-the-frying-pan exception exists), but I was specifically addressing the original complaint in my article.

As for Horace thinking &#039;the Gods exist but&#039; they could not
&lt;blockquote&gt;be relied upon to solve the personal problems of random mortals&lt;/blockquote&gt;

That brings up exactly the points I was making - Gods are either omniscient, omnipotent, and omnipresent, able to be anywhere and solve anything - or they are limited. Exactly the sort of restrictions are assumed by your analysis as those I have recommended in the article. So I think, in the final analysis, that we are actually in agreement!]]></description>
			<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p>In reply to <a href="https://www.campaignmastery.com/blog/the-plot-implications-of-divinity/comment-page-1/#comment-27797">Dan H</a>.</p>
<p>@Dan H: You wrote: </p>
<blockquote><p>If the criticism of a deus ex machina hinged on the assumption that deities aren’t real, it would not be possible to apply the term to phenomena which are physically possible in the real world, but it is.</p></blockquote>
<p>I&#8217;m afraid I have to sideways sort-of disagree with that statement. The original criticism hinged on the assumption that deities aren&#8217;t real and was a very specific complaint. The usage has since been broadened and generalized to include phenomena which are physically possible in the real world, such as your random millionaire.</p>
<p>Criticism of the literary device beyond that initial complaint are valid as far as they go (I still think an out-of-the-frying-pan exception exists), but I was specifically addressing the original complaint in my article.</p>
<p>As for Horace thinking &#8216;the Gods exist but&#8217; they could not</p>
<blockquote><p>be relied upon to solve the personal problems of random mortals</p></blockquote>
<p>That brings up exactly the points I was making &#8211; Gods are either omniscient, omnipotent, and omnipresent, able to be anywhere and solve anything &#8211; or they are limited. Exactly the sort of restrictions are assumed by your analysis as those I have recommended in the article. So I think, in the final analysis, that we are actually in agreement!</p>
]]></content:encoded>
		
			</item>
	</channel>
</rss>
